Why Employee Share Schemes Are Important for Business Success

Published by Mohsin Khan posted in Employee share schemes on January 7, 2025

Employee Share Schemes (ESS) let employees own shares in the company they work for. This helps them feel more connected to the company’s success. It also motivates them to work harder and stay loyal. ESS are great for companies of all sizes, especially those wanting to keep top talent.

With ESS, employees can feel like they’re part of the company’s future. They get a say in company matters and might even receive dividends. Plus, the company benefits too. 

ESS often leads to 

  • higher company performance 
  • better teamwork, and 
  • increased shareholder value

So, whether it’s direct share ownership or options, ESS is a win-win for both employees and employers. 

Want to explore the best option for your company?

Let’s discuss how you can leverage ESS to bring up:

  • The value of your company in the market.
  • Retain and foster top talent within your organisation.

Tax Benefits and Obligations Across Employee Share Schemes

A Complete Guide of Tax benefits and obligations

Employee share schemes offer great tax benefits, but each scheme has its own rules. Here’s a quick look at the tax benefits and obligations for different share schemes:

 

  • EMI: No income tax or NICs on grant or exercise if options are at market value. CGT is 10% after two years. Companies must notify HMRC within 92 days.
  • CSOP: No income tax or NICs if options are held for 3+ years at market value. Pay CGT when shares are sold.
  • SIP: No income tax, NICs, or CGT if shares are held for 5 years.
  • SAYE: No income tax or NICs on discounted share price after the savings period. Pay CGT on any gain when shares are sold.
  • Non-Approved: Growth Shares, RSUs, and EOTs have limited tax benefits. Income tax and CGT apply on gains.

These rules help ensure your scheme is tax-efficient and compliant.

Read more

Tax Implications of Employee Share Schemes

Understanding the Tax implications of Employee Share Schemes

HMRC-approved schemes offer tax benefits. 

  • For EMI, no income tax or NICs if options are granted at market value. CGT is 10% if shares are held for over two years. 
  • For CSOPs, no income tax or NICs if held for three years. CGT applies when shares are sold. 
  • SIPs offer no income tax or NICs if shares are held for five years. There’s no CGT if shares are sold from the SIP. 
  • SAYE allows employees to buy shares at a discount, with no tax if exercised after three years. 

Non-approved schemes, like 

  • growth shares and RSUs, require income tax and NICs when the shares vest. EOTs offer no income tax on bonuses up to £3,600.

Read more

Selecting the Right Employee Share Scheme

How to Select the Best Employee Share Plan Selection Guide for Your Business

Choosing the right employee share scheme depends on a few key factors.

Tax Benefits: 

EMI offers high tax advantages with no income tax or NICs. CSOPs and SIPs also have good tax benefits if shares are held long-term. SAYE has tax-free discounts, but CGT applies on gains.

Eligibility: 

EMI is for smaller companies with fewer than 250 employees. SIP is open to all employees. SAYE requires employees to meet a minimum service requirement.

Admin Complexity: 

EMI needs detailed record-keeping and HMRC reporting. SIP and CSOP are simpler but still need reporting. Growth shares need internal record-keeping.

Strategic Benefits: 

EMI attracts top talent. SIP motivates all employees. SAYE encourages saving. Growth shares are flexible and linked to performance.

Read more

Eligibility for Employee Share Schemes

A Guide to Eligibility Criteria for Different Employee Share Schemes

Employee share schemes offer great incentives, but eligibility matters. 

  • For the EMI scheme, companies need to be UK-based, with fewer than 250 employees and assets under £30 million. Employees must work at least 25 hours a week and cannot own more than 30% of the company’s shares. 
  • CSOPs allow companies of any size, but options must be granted at market value, with employees allowed up to £60,000 in options. 
  • SAYE schemes let all employees participate, saving monthly to buy shares at a discount after 3 to 5 years. 
  • SIPs offer shares to all employees, with tax benefits if held for five years. 

Read more

Compliance with HMRC for Employee Share Schemes

Everything You Need to Know About HMRC Compliance UK

To stay compliant with HMRC, both companies and employees must follow certain rules.

  • EMI: Companies must register the scheme with HMRC within 92 days and submit an annual return by 6 July. Employees report gains on their self-assessment tax return.
  • CSOPs: Companies report grants annually, and employees report exercised options and gains.
  • SIPs: Companies need HMRC approval and must report share awards annually. Employees report any early withdrawals.
  • SAYE: Companies register the scheme and report annually. Employees report shares sold on their tax return.
  • Growth Shares/RSUs: No specific HMRC reporting, but companies must report benefits as income. Employees report the value when shares vest.

Be sure to meet deadlines to avoid penalties!

Read more

HMRC-Approved and Non-Approved Share Schemes

Apex’s Support in Selecting the Right HMRC-Approved Scheme

HMRC-approved share schemes offer tax benefits. The EMI scheme is for small businesses with fewer than 250 employees and assets under £30 million. No income tax or NICs on the options if granted at market value. The CSOP allows up to £60,000 in options, with similar tax benefits if held for three years. SIPs let employees receive shares directly, with no income tax if held for five years. SAYE allows employees to save and buy shares at a discount after 3 to 5 years, without income tax. 

Non-approved schemes, like growth shares, RSUs, and EOTs, have different rules but still offer benefits. These schemes encourage long-term commitment and company growth.

Read more

Company Share Option Plans (CSOPs) Overview

Apex Accountants Explain How Company Share Option Plans (CSOPs) Can Optimise Your Tax & Employee Benefits

CSOPs are HMRC-approved schemes offering tax benefits to companies. There are no strict size limits for companies, but they must be trading companies, not investment firms, and independent. Subsidiaries can qualify if the parent company meets the rules. The share options must be granted at market value and be ordinary, fully paid, non-redeemable shares. Employees, including full-time directors, are eligible for the options. There’s no specific hours requirement for eligibility. However, options must be held for at least three years to benefit from tax advantages. For example, a tech company grants options at £10 per share. After three years, if the price rises to £20, the employee only pays CGT, not income tax.

Read more

Step-by-Step Process for Setting Up Employee Share Schemes

Understanding the Scheme implementation process

Setting up an employee share scheme involves a few key steps.

  • Define Goals: 

Decide if the goal is to attract talent, boost productivity, or retain staff.

  • Identify Participants: 

Choose who will join, like senior staff or all employees.

  • Pick the Scheme Type: 

Choose from schemes like EMI (for small businesses), CSOP (for larger companies), SIP (for many employees), or SAYE (for savings).

  • Design the Scheme: 

Set performance goals and define vesting periods, usually 3-5 years.

  • Get Approvals: 

Get board and shareholder approval and amend articles if needed.

  • Draft Legal Docs: 

Prepare documents like share agreements.

  • Register with HMRC: 

For tax-advantaged schemes, register with HMRC.

  • Communicate the Scheme: 

Explain it to employees.

  • Implement: 

Grant options, track progress, and stay compliant.

Read more

The Importance of Shareholder Agreements for Employee Share Schemes

A Complete Guide of How a Shareholder Agreement Can Secure Your Business Future

Employee Share Schemes (ESS) include plans like 

  • Growth Shares
  • Phantom Schemes, and 
  • Share Incentive Plans (SIPs)

These align employees’ interests with company goals.

Shareholder agreements and articles of association are key for ESS. They set up rules for share issuance, rights, and transfers.

Governance rights like voting and dividends are defined. They also outline dispute resolution methods. These agreements protect both employees and the company.

Articles of Association ensure new shares follow legal rules. They also cover vesting and exit provisions. 

For example, good leavers can keep shares, while bad leavers may lose them.

Read more

Vesting Periods and Conditions Overview

Vesting Periods

Vesting periods are key in employee share schemes. They vest when employees fully own their shares or options.

Cliff Vesting: 

Employees get all shares after a set time. Example: 1,000 shares after four years. If they leave early, they lose all shares.

Graded Vesting:

Employees get shares gradually. Example: 1,000 shares over four years. They get 25% each year.

Immediate Vesting: 

Employees get shares right away, with no waiting.

Vesting Types:

  • Performance-Based Vesting: Shares vest if performance goals are met, like 20% revenue growth.
  • Time-Based Vesting: Shares vest over time, like 20% per year for five years.

These vesting plans help retain and motivate employees.

Read more

How Apex Accountants Can Help You!

Apex Accountants offers expert help with 

  • HMRC-approved schemes like EMI and CSOPs. 
  • Ensure your company stays compliant and maximises tax benefits.
  • Guide you through share schemes like growth shares and RSUs. 
  • Help with vesting periods and retention strategies. 
  • Guidance on tax reliefs and capital gains tax for employees.
  • Assistance with personal tax services 

Contact us today for expert advice and tailored solutions to optimise your corporate tax and individual tax planning. Apex Accountants is here to support your business and employees.

Book A Free Consultation

Book a Free Consultation