Category: Value Added Tax (VAT)

VAT on Car Hire in the UK – What Businesses Need to Know

Posted on by Sidra

Car hire is a regular expense for many UK businesses, whether used for client meetings, site inspections, or short-term transport needs. Yet, the VAT on car hire can be complex and easily misunderstood. Many businesses make errors when reclaiming VAT or fail to maintain adequate documentation, which can result in rejected claims or HMRC penalties.

At Apex Accountants, we help businesses across the UK understand the correct VAT rules for car hire. Our VAT specialists offer precise advice on reclaiming VAT, maintaining compliant records, and anticipating HMRC’s expectations during reviews or audits. With extensive experience in tax and VAT compliance, we help clients manage vehicle-related VAT efficiently and confidently.

This article explains how VAT applies to car hire, the conditions for reclaiming it, and the differences between business and private use. It also outlines practical compliance measures businesses should follow to stay accurate and audit-ready.

What Is the VAT Rate for Car Hire in the UK?

Car hire in the UK is subject to 20% VAT, charged on the full rental cost. This includes additional fees such as insurance, delivery, fuel, or cleaning charges. Whether the hire is for a day, a week, or a month, the VAT rate remains the same. However, the ability to reclaim VAT depends entirely on how the vehicle is used, not just the price or duration of hire.

How to Reclaim VAT on Car Hire

According to HMRC VAT Notice 700/64, businesses can reclaim VAT on car rental only if the vehicle is used entirely for business purposes and is not available for private use. Any personal or non-business use — even minimal — makes the VAT non-recoverable.

To claim VAT correctly, companies must keep clear and consistent evidence showing that the hire was solely for business activity. This includes:

  • A valid VAT invoice issued by the hire company.
  • Written confirmation that the car was for business use only.
  • Detailed mileage logs and journey records.
  • Authorisation forms or internal documentation supporting business use.

When learning how to reclaim VAT on car hire, it’s essential to understand that HMRC requires strict proof of exclusive business use. For instance, if a director hires a car for site visits but drives it home overnight, that is considered private use — and VAT cannot be reclaimed.

Businesses that adhere to these documentation standards can recover input VAT legitimately while avoiding HMRC penalties or disallowed claims. Proper record-keeping ensures that claims are supported, compliant, and audit-ready.

When Is VAT on Car Hire Not Recoverable?

VAT cannot be reclaimed if a company car is available for personal use. This applies even when the majority of trips are business-related. For instance, if a director hires a car for a client visit but keeps it for a weekend getaway, HMRC will treat the VAT as non-recoverable.

Can VAT Be Reclaimed for Van or Commercial Vehicle Hire?

Yes. HMRC allows full VAT recovery on commercial vehicles, such as vans or trucks, because these are not classed as “cars” under VAT law. If a business exclusively uses a vehicle for commercial purposes and provides proper records and justification, they can claim VAT in full.

Case Study: Apex Accountants Supporting a Construction Client

A construction firm client of Apex Accountants regularly hired cars for site inspections across multiple regions. Initially, the company reclaimed VAT on all hire invoices, including instances where directors used the cars for personal travel.

Upon review, we identified non-compliant claims totalling over £8,700. We implemented a tracking and documentation process using mileage logs, travel purpose forms, and separate hire agreements for private use. The result:

  • Corrected past VAT errors before HMRC review.
  • Reclaimed legitimate VAT of £12,400 for pure business trips.
  • Improved compliance and reduced future risk of penalties.

Record-Keeping for Compliance

Businesses should always retain:

  • VAT invoices for each hire
  • Signed agreements stating “business use only”
  • Mileage and journey records
  • Any internal authorisation for vehicle use

Expert VAT Guidance from Apex Accountants

At Apex Accountants, we help UK businesses identify reclaimable VAT, correct past submission errors, and strengthen audit trails to withstand HMRC scrutiny. Our VAT specialists review complex hire arrangements, provide detailed advice, and support every eligible claim with accurate documentation and clear reasoning.

We regularly assist clients who struggle to interpret the VAT rules for car hire, helping them distinguish between what qualifies as business use and what HMRC may consider private use. This clarity prevents costly errors and ensures all claims are compliant and defensible during audits.

Whether your business hires vehicles for short-term projects, regional operations, or long-term contracts, our team offers tailored VAT guidance designed to protect your compliance status and support efficient cash flow. We also review existing VAT records to identify missed opportunities for legitimate recovery.

With a proven record of success across multiple industries, Apex Accountants combine technical expertise with practical solutions that simplify complex VAT requirements.

Contact us today to arrange a consultation and find out how our specialists can help you handle VAT on vehicle hire confidently and efficiently

£20 Million VAT Carousel Fraud Case: Lessons for UK Directors and Businesses

Posted on by Sidra

Nineteen people have been sentenced in one of the UK’s largest VAT fraud cases, after HMRC uncovered a sophisticated £20 million missing trader (MTIC) carousel scheme. The VAT carousel fraud ran for three years and involved fake business deals, falsified invoices, and fabricated offshore accounts designed to mislead the tax authorities.

The operation—code-named Operation Barbados—exposed a national network of directors who met secretly to plan how to manipulate their VAT declarations and conceal the true scale of their taxable transactions.

How the £20 Million VAT Carousal Fraud Worked

Between 2011 and 2014, Winnington Networks Ltd (WNL) and its associates submitted manipulated VAT returns that understated the amounts due to HMRC. The business appeared to trade in metals and electrical goods across EU borders, but in reality, many transactions were entirely fictitious.

Investigators later found that WNL used a carousel structure, where goods were repeatedly “sold” through a chain of UK and offshore companies to generate false VAT reclaims. To make the paperwork look legitimate, the group claimed to sell VOIP airtime to UK customers — a service that did not exist.

At two covert hotel meetings in Manchester and Birmingham, senior figures, including WNL’s finance director, discussed how to fabricate figures and “invent the numbers” to inflate VAT offsets. These conversations, captured by investigators, became key evidence in court.

The HMRC tax fraud was so detailed that the conspirators even created two fake online banking systems, supposedly located in the Seychelles and Canada, to produce convincing financial statements for auditors and suppliers.

HMRC’s Fraud Investigation Service, with support from UK and international law enforcement, dismantled the network after years of coordinated investigation.

Following four major trials at Southwark Crown Court, 20 individuals were convicted or pleaded guilty to offences including conspiracy to cheat the public’s revenue and money laundering.

Key sentences included:

  • Neil Pursell, 61 — former finance director, jailed for nine years and disqualified as a director for 14 years.
  • William Lindfield, 63 — jailed for seven years and six months and banned from being a director for eight years.
  • Vishal Chudasama, 42 — sentenced to three years and six months.
  • Other participants, including Kashaf Bashir, Adeel Malik, Sarah Peploe, and Beverley Thompson, received suspended sentences of up to two years.

In total, the combined prison terms exceeded 70 years, reflecting the scale and persistence of the conspiracy.

HMRC confirmed that proceeds-of-crime recovery actions have begun to reclaim stolen public funds. Judge Dafna Spiro described the enterprise as a “highly sophisticated attack on the UK tax system”.

Why This HMRC Tax Fraud Matters for Every UK Business

Winnington Networks Ltd VAT fraud is a sharp reminder that HMRC takes VAT fraud extremely seriously and that even complex schemes are traceable through modern technology.

HMRC’s Connect data-matching system now cross-references company filings, VAT submissions, imports, and even director information. Businesses with irregular VAT patterns, unrealistic refund claims, or unexplained supply chains can trigger automated red-flags.

Common VAT Risks That Attract HMRC Scrutiny

  • Reclaiming input VAT from invalid or non-existent invoices.
  • Buying from or selling to unverified suppliers.
  • Entering supply chains with unusual profit margins or circular trading.
  • Incomplete bookkeeping or inconsistent VAT returns.

Unknowingly linking businesses to fraudulent supply chains can lead to financial penalties, director disqualification, or public prosecution.

Apex Accountants’ View and Recommendations

The £20 million VAT carousel fraud uncovered by Operation Barbados highlights the importance of strong financial controls and transparent reporting. At Apex Accountants & Tax Advisors, we view this as a clear reminder that every business must stay alert to VAT compliance risks.

Fraud of this scale shows that even legitimate companies can face scrutiny if linked to suspicious trading networks. To stay protected, we recommend:

  • Verifying suppliers and customers through VAT registration and due-diligence checks.
  • Using cloud accounting systems for real-time monitoring and audit trails.
  • Conducting regular VAT compliance reviews with qualified professionals.
  • Maintaining clear records of transactions and correspondence.

Our VAT experts help UK businesses strengthen compliance under Making Tax Digital (MTD), identify red flags early, and reduce exposure to HMRC penalties. Strong governance and consistent oversight remain the best defence against fraud and reputational damage.

How Apex Accountants Helps Businesses Avoid VAT Risks

At Apex Accountants & Tax Advisors, we support businesses across the UK with compliance-focused VAT management to reduce exposure to HMRC penalties.

Our services include:

  • VAT compliance reviews and supply-chain verification.
  • Digital VAT submissions compliant with Making Tax Digital (MTD).
  • VAT audit support, including preparation for HMRC inspections.
  • Risk-based bookkeeping and transaction monitoring using cloud-based accounting software.
  • Representation and correspondence with HMRC in the event of a review or investigation.

We help directors understand their obligations, correct errors before they escalate, and build a transparent financial record that protects their business reputation.

If you’re unsure about your VAT procedures or believe your business could face compliance risks, our team can provide confidential guidance and practical solutions.

Final Thoughts

The Winnington Networks Ltd VAT fraud shows how financial misconduct, even when disguised through layers of fake paperwork, can be uncovered through persistent investigation. For honest UK businesses, the lesson is clear: maintain accurate records, verify your suppliers, and seek professional VAT advice before submitting returns. Speak to Apex Accountants today for expert VAT support and peace of mind.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

VAT carousel fraud — also called Missing Trader Intra-Community (MTIC) fraud — happens when fraudsters create fake trade chains to claim VAT refunds on transactions that never occurred. The same goods are often circulated repeatedly across borders to reclaim VAT multiple times.

In a carousel fraud, a company imports goods VAT-free from an EU or overseas supplier, sells them in the UK with VAT added, and then disappears without paying HMRC. The goods are then resold through a series of shell companies and eventually re-exported, creating a “carousel” of false VAT claims.

3. What is an example of VAT fraud?

A business might buy mobile phones from an EU supplier without VAT, sell them on in the UK with VAT added, and vanish before paying HMRC. Another linked company later claims a refund for the VAT it supposedly paid, allowing fraudsters to profit from the fake transaction chain.

4. What is the biggest tax fraud in history?

The Cum-Ex trading scandal in Europe is considered the largest tax fraud ever uncovered, costing EU governments more than €55 billion. In the UK, large-scale VAT carousel schemes such as those exposed by HMRC have resulted in hundreds of millions of pounds in lost revenue.

5. How does HMRC detect VAT fraud?

HMRC uses advanced analytics through its Connect system to track VAT submissions, banking data, and import/export activity. This system automatically compares business records, company filings, and financial transactions to detect inconsistencies or patterns of fraud.

6. What penalties apply for VAT fraud in the UK?

VAT fraud can lead to unlimited fines, repayment of the stolen VAT, director disqualification for up to 15 years, and even imprisonment of up to 10 years. In serious cases, courts may also issue Serious Crime Prevention Orders (SCPOs) restricting future business activity.

7. Can a business be penalised for VAT errors even if unintentional?

Yes. HMRC can apply penalties when a business fails to take “reasonable care.” Even accidental VAT errors may lead to fines ranging from 15% to 100% of the tax owed, depending on whether the error was careless, deliberate, or concealed.

8. What should I do if HMRC suspects my business of VAT fraud?

If you receive a letter or visit from HMRC, don’t ignore it. Gather your VAT records, review your filings, and seek professional representation immediately. Prompt, well-advised responses can prevent escalation and demonstrate cooperation during an investigation.

VAT carousel fraud often involves sectors dealing in high-value, easily traded goods such as mobile phones, computer chips, and precious metals. In recent years, HMRC has also identified similar risks in carbon credits, electronics, and telecom services. These sectors are attractive to fraudsters because goods can be moved quickly and documentation can be falsified with ease.

10. How can businesses prevent VAT fraud?

  • Verify all trading partners through VAT registration checks.
  • Keep accurate and digital records of every sale and purchase.
  • Use Making Tax Digital (MTD)-compliant software.
  • Review your VAT processes regularly with professional accountants.
  • Report suspicious transactions or invoice patterns to HMRC.

At Apex Accountants & Tax Advisors, we provide VAT compliance reviews, supplier verification checks, and audit support to protect your business from fraud and HMRC penalties.

VAT Registration for SPVs for Properties: What You Need to Know

Posted on by Sidra

In the UK property market, Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) are commonly used to own, manage, or sell property projects while keeping financial risks separate. Yet many investors remain unsure about the process of VAT registration for SPVs for properties, which can affect pricing, financing, and transaction timelines if not handled correctly.

At Apex Accountants, we guide developers, landlords, and investors through VAT registration and compliance for property SPVs. Our team helps clients determine when VAT applies, structure transactions efficiently, and meet HMRC requirements.

This article explores the VAT rules for property SPVs, explaining when registration becomes necessary, how the option to tax operates, and which documents are required. It also highlights important VAT considerations for property sales and lettings to help prevent costly errors.

What Is a Property SPV?

A property SPV is a limited company created to hold or manage a specific property or development project. It allows investors to isolate financial and legal risks from their wider business interests.

Developers often use one SPV per project, which simplifies accounting, funding, and disposal. However, this structure brings unique VAT considerations depending on the SPV’s activities and the type of property involved.

When Can a Property SPV Register for VAT?

A property SPV can register for VAT only if it carries out an economic activity involving taxable supplies. Examples include the sale or letting of opted-to-tax commercial property or construction of taxable developments.

For investors wondering, can a property SPV be VAT registered, the answer depends on its activities. If the SPV merely holds land or property without generating income, it does not qualify as an active trading business and therefore cannot register for VAT. Each SPV’s position must be assessed individually, considering the nature of its income and expenditure.

VAT Registration Thresholds

VAT registration becomes mandatory when the SPV’s taxable turnover exceeds £90,000 in a 12-month period.

If turnover is below this threshold, the SPV may still register voluntarily to recover VAT on eligible costs — such as professional fees, construction, or refurbishment expenses — where it makes or intends to make taxable supplies.

Why VAT Matters in Property Transactions

VAT has a direct impact on the sale price, cash flow, and financing of a property. Many sellers discover their VAT position too late, creating confusion for buyers and lenders. If the seller has opted to tax, VAT becomes chargeable on the sale, increasing the total price and affecting how the buyer structures their funding. Buyers also need to know the VAT treatment early to confirm whether they can reclaim VAT or if a Transfer of a Going Concern (TOGC) applies. Without clarity on VAT status or key documents like a valid VAT number, option-to-tax confirmation, and compliant VAT invoice, deals can face serious delays or even collapse.

The Option to Tax and Documentation Requirements

Most property transactions are exempt from VAT by default. However, a property SPV can choose to opt to tax its land or building, converting future supplies into taxable ones.
This election must be supported by proper paperwork and notification to HMRC. Essential documents include:

  • Option to Tax Confirmation: Evidence that the SPV has opted to tax and notified HMRC.
  • Valid VAT Number: Confirmation that the SPV is VAT registered and compliant.
  • VAT-Compliant Invoices: Necessary for buyers to reclaim VAT on purchases.
    Missing or incomplete documentation is one of the most common reasons for transaction delays during property sales.

How VAT Recovery Works in Property SPVs

VAT recovery depends on the SPV’s activities:

  • Exempt Supplies: No input VAT recovery is allowed.
  • Taxable Supplies: Full recovery is permitted for related costs.
  • Mixed Activities: Partial exemption rules apply, requiring apportionment between recoverable and non-recoverable VAT.

If the SPV has opted to tax, it can reclaim VAT on property-related expenses, such as legal fees, building works, and management services. Where multiple properties or SPVs are involved, group VAT registration may also be considered for administrative efficiency.

Key Scenarios for Property SPVs

1. Exempt Property Lettings

SPVs letting property without opting to tax will not charge VAT on rents and cannot recover VAT on maintenance or acquisition costs.

2. Opted Commercial Property

Where an SPV opts to tax, rents and sales become taxable, enabling recovery of VAT on professional and construction costs. This option is useful for commercial developers and landlords.

3. Sale of New Commercial Property

Sales of new commercial buildings (less than three years old) are automatically subject to VAT. SPVs selling such properties must charge VAT but can also recover VAT incurred on development costs.

4. Residential Developments

Sales or long leases of new residential properties are zero-rated, allowing VAT recovery on construction costs but no VAT charge to the buyer. However, subsequent sales or lettings are usually exempt.

5. Transfer of a Going Concern (TOGC)

If an SPV sells a property rental business to another VAT-registered buyer who continues the same activity, the sale may qualify as a TOGC. In that case, the transaction falls outside the scope of VAT, provided both parties meet all conditions. This treatment helps avoid unnecessary VAT charges and cash-flow issues.

Buyer Considerations and SPV VAT Registration

Buyers purchasing through a newly formed SPV must ensure that it is properly VAT registered before completion. Without registration, the buyer may not be able to reclaim VAT on the purchase, affecting cash flow and increasing costs.
Coordinating with accountants early in the process helps prevent delays and guarantees correct VAT treatment. Buyers should also confirm whether a TOGC applies and review the seller’s option-to-tax documents in advance.

For buyers asking, can a property SPV be VAT registered, it’s important to review the planned property activity early. Registration decisions must align with an intended use and investment strategy to maintain compliance and reclaim input VAT correctly.

Common Pitfalls and Mistakes

Property transactions often fail or face delays due to VAT errors. Frequent issues include:

  • Failing to verify the VAT position before marketing or purchasing a property.
  • Not notifying HMRC of an option to tax within 30 days.
  • Assuming all property income is automatically taxable.
  • Applying partial exemption incorrectly.
  • Forgetting that share sales of SPVs are exempt from VAT.
  • Not registering the buyer’s SPV in time to reclaim VAT.

Proactive VAT planning avoids last-minute complications and supports a smoother transaction.

Best Practices for Managing VAT in Property SPVs

  1. Confirm VAT Status Early: Establish whether VAT applies before marketing or purchasing the property.
  2. Maintain Proper Documentation: Keep the option-to-tax notification, VAT registration details, and invoices ready for review.
  3. Consult VAT Specialists: Professional guidance ensures compliance and helps optimise VAT recovery.
  4. Coordinate with Accountants: Buyers using SPVs should involve their accountants early to manage VAT registration correctly.
  5. Communicate Clearly: Transparency between sellers, buyers, and lenders prevents avoidable delays.
  6. Review Partial Exemption Calculations: Regularly verify apportionments to stay compliant.
  7. Prepare for HMRC Scrutiny: Keep evidence of all VAT decisions, calculations, and correspondence.

How Apex Accountants Supports VAT Registration for SPVs for Properties

At Apex Accountants, we specialise in VAT planning and compliance for property SPVs. We help property developers, landlords, and investors:

  • Determine VAT eligibility and register efficiently.
  • Prepare and submit option-to-tax documentation.
  • Handle partial exemption calculations.
  • Advise on TOGC treatment and transaction structuring.
  • Liaise with HMRC to resolve VAT disputes or audits.

Our experienced advisers apply detailed VAT rules for property SPVs to help clients stay compliant while maximising recovery opportunities. We ensure every SPV operates within HMRC requirements while staying commercially viable and tax-efficient.

Conclusion

An SPV property can register for VAT if it makes taxable supplies or opts to tax its property. However, VAT in property transactions is complex and must be addressed early. Missing documentation, late registration, or unclear tax positions can delay or derail deals.

By confirming VAT status early, keeping accurate records, and involving qualified accountants, both sellers and buyers can protect their cash flow and complete transactions without unnecessary setbacks. Apex Accountants provides expert guidance to keep every property SPV compliant, efficient, and deal-ready.

Contact us today to discuss your SPV VAT strategy and protect your business from costly HMRC challenges.

Comprehensive Advice on VAT for Market Research Companies in the UK

Posted on by Sidra

Foreign research agencies entering the UK market face complex VAT obligations that directly impact pricing and profitability. When it comes to VAT for market research companies, factors such as identifying the location of service delivery and determining whether clients qualify for the reverse charge mechanism are crucial.

Inbound research agencies often deal with a mix of client types, digital deliverables, and project-related expenses that may fall under varied VAT categories. Without a clear grasp of UK tax law, even established international firms risk overpaying VAT or losing out on legitimate reclaims.

At Apex Accountants, we provide expert cross-border VAT advice for market research companies, helping international agencies manage compliance, structure operations efficiently, and optimise VAT recovery within the UK.

How the UK Treats Market Research Services for VAT

The UK classifies market research and consultancy as services of consultants. Under Schedule 4A of the VAT Act 1994, consultancy and research services supplied to non-UK customers are usually taxed where the customer belongs. HMRC confirms this in its official VAT place-of-supply guidance.

This definition forms the basis for VAT treatment of both business-to-business and business-to-consumer research services.

Registration Rules for Non-UK Market Research Firms

The UK classifies foreign firms operating in the country as non-established taxable persons (NETPs). The £90,000 VAT registration threshold does not apply to them. A firm must register for VAT before making its first taxable UK supply. 

Digital services — such as access to dashboards, research software, or online reports — always require UK VAT registration. When services are provided only to UK businesses registered for VAT, the reverse charge applies, allowing the UK client to self-account for VAT instead of the supplier.

Use and Enjoyment Rules 

The use-and-enjoyment rules ensure that VAT applies where the service is consumed. If the customer is based abroad and uses market research outputs in the UK, VAT may be due. Contracts should specify how and where reports, data, or insights will be used. This clarity helps avoid disputes and unplanned VAT exposure.

Determining the Place of Supply

Business-to-Business (B2B) Supplies

Under the general B2B rule, services are supplied where the business customer belongs. When a foreign research agency sells services to a UK VAT-registered company, the UK client accounts for VAT under the reverse charge mechanism.  

The supplier issues an invoice stating that the reverse charge applies. This approach avoids the need for the overseas supplier to charge UK VAT directly. 

Business-to-Consumer (B2C) Supplies

For B2C services, the place of supply is usually where the supplier belongs.However, for professional or consultancy services — including market research — the place of supply is where the customer belongs. Therefore, when a non-UK research firm serves a UK private client, the service is deemed supplied in the UK. The supplier must register for and charge UK VAT from the first transaction.

Digital Services

Digital services include electronically supplied activities such as downloads, subscriptions, or online research platforms. These are always taxed where the consumer resides. Foreign firms selling digital market research services to UK customers must register for VAT immediately. They must also verify whether the client is a business or a consumer, keeping evidence such as VAT numbers or company records.

Reclaiming UK VAT

Foreign market research firms often incur UK VAT on expenses such as travel, venue hire, subcontractors, or data licensing. There are two main ways to recover this VAT:

  • VAT Registration: Firms registered for UK VAT reclaim input VAT through their UK VAT returns.
  • 13th Directive Refund: Non-UK businesses with no UK establishment and no taxable UK supplies may reclaim VAT via the 13th Directive process. Claims must be supported by original invoices and business certificates and submitted within HMRC deadlines.
     

These reclaim mechanisms are crucial for reducing operational costs and maintaining profitability.

Common VAT Mistakes by Inbound Research Firms

Foreign research agencies frequently make similar VAT errors:

  • Registering late or assuming a threshold applies to non-UK firms 
  • Failing to verify client VAT status and misclassifying B2B transactions as B2C
  • Ignoring use-and-enjoyment rules that shift VAT to the UK
  • Overlooking VAT obligations for digital or subscription services 
  • Maintaining incomplete records of invoices and client documentation

Avoiding these mistakes is essential to stay compliant and prevent HMRC penalties.

VAT Optimisation Strategies

Strong planning and VAT compliance for research agencies help avoid costly mistakes and improve financial efficiency. For inbound market research firms, proactive VAT management ensures accurate reporting, better cash flow, and reduced risk of penalties.

  1. Confirm client status early. Check VAT registration numbers and determine whether each client is a business or consumer.
  2. Classify your services correctly. Distinguish between consultancy and digital services, as VAT registration rules differ.
  3. Define use and enjoyment clearly. Include service-use clauses in contracts to show where work is consumed.
  4. Plan VAT registration strategically. Register only when required; rely on the reverse charge for B2B supplies when possible.
  5. Reclaim input VAT promptly. File accurate VAT returns or 13th Directive claims before deadlines. 
  6. Stay updated. Review HMRC and post-Brexit VAT changes regularly to maintain compliance.

Proactive planning reduces administrative costs and protects against unexpected VAT liabilities.

How Apex Accountants Help with VAT for Market Research Companies

Apex Accountants specialise in providing tailored financial support and cross-border VAT advice for market research companies operating in the UK. We offer

  • VAT registration and compliance support for non-UK suppliers
  • Setup of reverse-charge invoicing and reporting systems
  • Evidence management for customer verification and record keeping
  • Assistance with 13th Directive refund applications
  • Ongoing advice and updates on VAT law changes

Our goal is to make VAT management simple, transparent, and cost-effective for international research businesses entering the UK market.

Conclusion

Effective VAT management is vital for international research firms entering the UK market. Understanding local regulations, registration duties, and reclaim procedures helps businesses maintain accuracy and reduce financial risk. With the right planning and professional guidance, firms can simplify tax processes and focus on growth rather than compliance concerns. At Apex Accountants, we deliver expert VAT compliance for research agencies, helping businesses meet their obligations with confidence and clarity. Contact Apex Accountants today to discuss how our tailored services can support your financial and operational goals.

VAT Challenges for Smart Device Retailers and Appliance Distributors in 2026

Posted on by Sidra

The smart technology and appliance market continues to expand rapidly in the UK. With increasing consumer demand, bundled services, and digital sales, retailers and distributors must stay ahead of complex VAT rules. In 2026, VAT challenges for smart device retailers are expected to become more frequent and technical—especially as HMRC prepares to tighten its digital oversight and enforcement powers.

At Apex Accountants, we support UK smart tech retailers and appliance distributors in managing VAT risks with practical, sector-specific advice. Our team understands the operational pressures you face—from high-volume online sales to trade-in programmes, international transactions, and margin-based resales. We offer tech retailers VAT advice that aligns with both compliance and commercial objectives.

This article outlines the key VAT issues businesses in this space need to address in 2026. From bundled supplies and voucher schemes to MTD compliance and cross-border movement, we explore where the pitfalls lie—and how to avoid them.

Major VAT Compliance Issues for Device and Appliance Sellers

Retailers and distributors in the smart tech and appliance sector face growing VAT complexity in 2026. From bundled sales to digital services and cross-border rules, each area requires careful attention to avoid costly errors. The following points outline the most common VAT compliance issues businesses should review and address.

1. Complexities in Bundled Sales

Most retailers offer bundled deals—such as a smart speaker with installation or a fridge with an extended warranty. These can qualify as either:

  • Single composite supplies (taxed at one VAT rate), or
  • Multiple supplies (each part taxed separately).

HMRC applies the economic reality test. Misclassification can lead to underpaid VAT. It’s essential to:

  • Document each bundle
  • Assess the VAT liability of every element
  • Maintain consistent pricing logic.

2. Digital Services and Subscriptions

Many smart devices now include access to apps or cloud-based platforms. If you’re selling to UK consumers, standard VAT applies. But for EU or global customers:

  • Place of supply rules apply
  • You may need non-Union OSS registration, or
  • Direct local VAT registration in certain countries.

Review each revenue stream and confirm where the service is consumed.

3. Refurbished Goods and Trade-ins

Refurbishment and trade-in schemes are growing in popularity. Retailers dealing in second-hand stock may qualify for the VAT Margin Scheme, provided:

  • Input VAT wasn’t reclaimed on purchase
  • Goods are eligible (e.g. used smartphones or laptops)
  • Full purchase records are kept

Only the margin between purchase and resale is taxed—saving VAT, but requiring strict recordkeeping.

4. Voucher Schemes and Loyalty Programmes

Smart device retailers often issue:

  • Single-purpose vouchers (known VAT rate and place of supply) — VAT due on issue.
  • Multi-purpose vouchers (used for different goods/services) — VAT due on redemption.

Misclassification affects when VAT is reported. Retailers should:

  • Align voucher codes with POS systems
  • Monitor redemption data for accurate returns

5. Retail Schemes and Cashflow

HMRC offers Retail Schemes for businesses making high volumes of low-value sales. These include:

  • Point of Sale
  • Apportionment or
  • Direct calculation methods

Each must be agreed with HMRC and applied consistently. Choosing the wrong scheme, or applying it incorrectly, can lead to assessments.

6. Great Britain–Northern Ireland Movements

The Windsor Framework governs GB–NI trade. From 2025:

  • The green lane applies for UK-only goods
  • Parcel data sharing becomes mandatory
  • VAT treatment differs based on supply chain position.

Retailers must correctly classify goods and keep supporting evidence to use simplified processes.

7. VAT Registration Threshold and Making Tax Digital for Retailers

The VAT threshold rose to £90,000 in April 2024. If turnover exceeds this over any rolling 12-month period, registration is mandatory. From the first return, you must:

  • Comply with Making Tax Digital for retailers
  • Use compatible software
  • Keep digital records

Late registration or MTD non-compliance can trigger penalties.

Case Study: Overcoming VAT Challenges in Smart Device Retail

A UK-based smart device retailer approached Apex Accountants in 2025, facing a series of VAT compliance issues. Their bundled sales—combining devices, installation, and digital subscriptions—were incorrectly classified, leading to VAT errors. They were also unsure how to handle VAT on EU digital service sales and needed clarity on whether their refurbished product line qualified for the VAT Margin Scheme. With the Making Tax Digital mandate approaching, their internal systems were unprepared for digital reporting.

Apex Accountants carried out a full VAT health check. We developed a framework to properly classify bundled vs multiple supplies, handled OSS registration for EU sales, and structured the refurbished goods process to correctly apply the VAT Margin Scheme. We also migrated the retailer to MTD-compliant software, linked it with their POS system, and trained staff on digital recordkeeping.

Following implementation, the business achieved full VAT compliance, avoided penalties, and improved reporting accuracy. The retailer now operates confidently, knowing their VAT processes align with UK and international requirements.

How Apex Accountants Helps Tackle VAT Challenges for Smart Device Retailers

At Apex Accountants, we support smart tech retailers and distributors with tailored VAT advice. Whether you’re managing international app sales, refurbished goods, or bundled devices, we’ll:

  • Clarify supply classifications
  • Review voucher and margin schemes
  • Assist with OSS and MTD compliance
  • Offer regular VAT health checks

Our proactive approach helps you avoid penalties, protect cash flow, and stay fully compliant with evolving VAT requirements. We specialise in VAT advice for tech retailers looking to grow sustainably and meet sector-specific obligations with confidence.

With VAT rules becoming more technical and digital reporting now a core requirement, having expert support is no longer optional—it’s essential to future-proof your business.

Contact Apex Accountants today to arrange your VAT compliance review.

A Practical Guide to VAT Treatment of Agricultural Insurance

Posted on by Sidra

Agricultural insurance plays a key role in safeguarding UK farmers against unpredictable risks such as crop failure, livestock disease, and extreme weather. However, the VAT treatment of agricultural insurance remains a complex area, often leading to uncertainty for insurers, brokers, and farming clients. This includes issues around exemptions, input VAT restrictions, and sector-specific schemes such as the Agricultural Flat Rate Scheme (AFRS). The rules require careful interpretation and tailored advice to ensure correct compliance and accurate VAT recovery.

At Apex Accountants, we work closely with insurers and agri-businesses to resolve these issues. Our expertise covers everything from partial exemption methods and VAT recovery strategies to classification of hybrid or parametric policies. We understand the operational pressures in this field and provide solutions tailored to the agricultural insurance market.

This article explores the current agricultural insurance VAT treatment in the UK. It outlines key compliance challenges and highlights practical opportunities for improved VAT recovery.

Current VAT Treatment in the UK

Agricultural insurance is treated as an exempt supply under the UK VAT Act 1994. Therefore, insurers do not charge VAT on premiums. Instead, they pay Insurance Premium Tax (IPT)—currently 12% for most general insurance and 20% for some policies like motor or travel insurance.

While premiums are VAT-free, this also means insurers cannot reclaim input VAT on operational expenses such as claims handling, consultancy, IT systems, or legal support. For large insurers, unrecoverable VAT can run into six or seven figures annually. That’s why understanding the VAT rules for agricultural insurers is critical for profitability and compliance.

Main VAT Challenges

Input VAT Non-Recovery

Because the supply is exempt, insurers cannot recover VAT on services linked to policy administration, digital tools, loss adjustment, or marketing. This inflates operating costs and can affect premium competitiveness.

Partial Exemption Complexity

Insurers providing both taxable and exempt services must calculate their recoverable VAT using a partial exemption special method (PESM) or standard method. This is administratively burdensome and often leads to errors or overpayments.

Grey Areas in Classification

Modern insurance policies—such as those covering drought, crop yield, or climate-triggered losses—may include parametric elements. Payments tied to a pre-agreed event rather than an actual loss raise concerns about the supply’s continued exemption.

Interaction with Farmer Schemes

Many farmers use the AFRS, which complicates VAT recovery and accounting for both insurers and intermediaries. Insurers must carefully document and categorise these interactions to avoid mismatches and HMRC scrutiny.

VAT Neutrality Concerns

VAT neutrality is lost when insurers can’t reclaim input VAT. This distorts pricing and disincentivises innovation in new products or platforms.

To address these issues, businesses often turn to experienced professionals for VAT advice for agricultural businesses. Correct classification and recovery methods can have a significant impact on financial outcomes.

Case Study: Helping an Agricultural Insurer Improve VAT Recovery

A UK-based mutual insurer offering drought and livestock policies to over 2,500 farming clients was unable to recover £180,000 in VAT over two years. Their in-house team relied on a default VAT recovery method that didn’t reflect their mixed-use operations, which included weather monitoring services and a digital advisory platform.

Apex Accountants stepped in to review their VAT treatment. We applied for a Partial Exemption Special Method (PESM) that better aligned with actual business use. We also identified parts of the business offering taxable consultancy services and reclassified them accordingly. To improve accuracy moving forward, we advised upgrading their invoice tracking and categorisation systems.

As a result, the client reclaimed £68,000 in VAT and now recovers 28% of input VAT annually. This has improved their pricing model and made them more competitive across southern England.

Opportunities for the Sector

  • Clearer guidance from HMRC on hybrid and parametric products could reduce classification disputes.
  • Subsidies or grants could help offset the cost of unrecoverable VAT for insurers focusing on vulnerable regions.
  • Technology upgrades to track taxable vs. exempt use of resources may increase recovery rates.
  • Better apportionment models could reduce compliance risk and simplify annual VAT returns.

To adapt to these changes, insurers must stay updated on VAT rules for agricultural insurers and work with advisors who understand the sector.

How Apex Accountants Simplifies VAT Treatment of Agricultural Insurance

Navigating VAT in the agricultural insurance sector requires more than just technical knowledge—it demands industry-specific insight. Apex Accountants combines deep sector experience with practical, tailored solutions. We understand the unique challenges around exempt supplies, Insurance Premium Tax (IPT), partial exemption rules, and HMRC compliance.

Whether you’re an insurer, broker, or agri-business, our team provides clear and practical VAT advice for agricultural businesses. We help structure your operations efficiently, reduce unrecoverable VAT costs, and stay ahead of regulatory risk. With nearly two decades of experience, we offer hands-on support to improve your VAT position and protect your bottom line.

To discuss how we can support your business, contact Apex Accountants today.

Do Hairdressers Charge VAT in the UK?

Posted on by Sidra

The question, “Do hairdressers charge VAT in the UK?” is one that many salon owners, freelance stylists, and mobile hairdressers often ask. The answer depends not on the type of business, but on turnover. Hairdressers in the UK must follow HMRC’s VAT (Value Added Tax) rules, which link directly to income thresholds. Once a business exceeds the set level, it must register for VAT, affecting pricing, profit margins, and customer perception.

This article provides a detailed explanation of VAT requirements for hairdressers. It covers the registration threshold, rules for different business models, exemptions, the standard VAT rate, and the practical effects on the hairdressing industry. It also highlights how Apex Accountants can help hairdressers manage VAT effectively.

What is the VAT registration threshold for hairdressers?

The VAT registration threshold is the first factor to consider. As of April 2024, the threshold stands at £90,000 in annual taxable turnover. This means that if a hairdresser, salon, or barber shop earns more than £90,000 in any consecutive twelve months, they must register for VAT with HMRC.

It is important to note that this is a rolling 12-month period. Businesses cannot simply measure from the start to the end of a tax year. For example, if a salon gradually increases its monthly turnover and reaches £90,000 over the course of May to April, the VAT registration requirement applies from that point. HMRC requires businesses to register within 30 days of crossing the threshold.

On the other hand, if turnover later drops below £88,000, a hairdresser may apply for deregistration. This flexibility helps businesses that experience seasonal fluctuations or temporary drops in revenue. However, many businesses in the sector deliberately remain under the threshold to avoid the administrative burden and financial implications of VAT.

Do all hairdressers have to charge VAT once registered?

The obligation to charge VAT does not depend on the type of business. Whether someone is a self-employed stylist, a salon owner, or a mobile hairdresser, the same rule applies: once the threshold is exceeded, VAT registration is compulsory and VAT must be charged.

  • Independent and self-employed hairdressers must register when their annual earnings from services and product sales go above £90,000. Until then, they do not charge VAT.
  • Salon businesses must take a wider view of turnover. Income from services, retail sales, and even chair rental fees from freelancers all count toward the threshold. Once this total passes £90,000, VAT registration is unavoidable.
  • Chair rental arrangements can tip many salons into VAT. HMRC clarified that chair rentals are taxable at the standard rate, meaning this income cannot be excluded.
  • Mobile hairdressers, who often earn below the threshold, usually do not charge VAT. However, if their earnings grow – perhaps by catering to events, building a larger client base, or hiring additional help – VAT may come into play.

Employees working in salons never charge VAT personally. Instead, the salon or company they work for is responsible for VAT registration and collection.

Are there any VAT exemptions for hairdressers?

There are no sector-specific VAT exemptions for hairdressers. In other words, there is no special rule that removes hairdressers from the VAT system. All standard services, such as cutting, colouring, and styling, are taxable at the standard rate.

The only exemption is the small business exemption, which applies automatically if turnover remains under the £90,000 threshold. Hairdressers in this category do not charge VAT to clients and cannot reclaim VAT on expenses. Some choose to register voluntarily to appear more established or to reclaim VAT on products, equipment, or utilities. However, once registered, they must add VAT to every taxable service and sale.

What VAT rate applies to hairdressing services?

Hairdressing services are subject to the standard VAT rate of 20%. Unlike some sectors, such as hospitality, which temporarily benefited from a reduced VAT rate during COVID-19, hairdressers have always remained at the standard rate.

For example, a £50 haircut advertised before VAT becomes £60 once VAT is added. Many salons therefore prefer to display VAT-inclusive prices to avoid confusing clients. While customers of VAT-registered businesses pay more, customers of smaller, unregistered salons or mobile hairdressers do not pay VAT on top of quoted prices.

Some salons make use of HMRC’s Flat Rate Scheme. Under this scheme, a hairdressing business still charges clients the full 20% VAT but pays HMRC a fixed percentage of gross turnover (around 13% for hairdressers). This approach simplifies VAT accounting and reduces administrative pressure, though it may not suit every business.

How does VAT affect pricing and profits for hairdressers?

VAT for hairdressers has a significant impact on pricing. Once registered, a hairdresser has two main choices:

  1. Increase prices by around 20% so the VAT is passed directly to customers. This can make services appear less competitive compared to non-registered stylists.
  2. Absorb the VAT cost and keep prices the same, but sacrifice part of the profit margin. This is often unsustainable in the long term.

Because hairdressing is labour-intensive, there are relatively few VAT-bearing expenses to claim. Wages and chair rent, for instance, do not attract VAT. As a result, many salons observe that they cannot reclaim enough input VAT to offset what they owe, making VAT registration a real challenge for profitability.

This pressure has led to calls within the industry for a reduced VAT rate, but as of 2025, no such relief has been introduced.

Conclusion: Do hairdressers charge VAT in the UK?

  • Hairdressers only charge VAT if they are VAT-registered.
  • Registration is compulsory once turnover exceeds £90,000 in any rolling 12 months.
  • VAT applies equally to salons, self-employed stylists, and mobile hairdressers.
  • All services are taxed at the standard 20% rate.
  • No specific VAT exemptions exist for the sector.

Smaller operators below the threshold do not charge VAT, which is why many remain outside the VAT system. Larger salons and growing freelancers, however, must register and adjust their pricing strategies accordingly.

How Apex Accountants can help hairdressers with VAT

For many in the hair and beauty industry, VAT is one of the most difficult financial challenges. At Apex Accountants, we work closely with salon owners, freelance stylists, and mobile hairdressers to make VAT management simpler and less stressful.

Our VAT services for hairdressers include:

  • Monitoring turnover and advising when VAT registration is required.
  • Registering businesses for VAT and handling deregistration when appropriate.
  • Preparing and filing VAT returns with HMRC.
  • Advising on pricing strategies that maintain competitiveness while staying compliant.
  • Exploring schemes such as the Flat Rate Scheme to simplify VAT reporting.
  • Representing clients in communications with HMRC and ensuring all obligations are met.

By partnering with Apex Accountants, hairdressers can focus on delivering great service to clients while we take care of VAT, compliance, and financial strategy.

Book a free consultation with Apex Accountants today and let us help your hairdressing business grow with confidence.

FAQs on VAT for Hairdressers and Beauty Salons in the UK

1. What is the VAT rate for hairdressers in the UK?

Hairdressing services in the UK are taxed at the standard VAT rate of 20%. This applies to all haircuts, styling, colouring, and similar services once a business is VAT-registered.

2. Is there VAT on beauty products in the UK?

Yes. Most beauty products, such as shampoos, conditioners, hair dyes, and cosmetics, are subject to the standard VAT rate of 20%. Only a few items, like certain health-related products, may fall under reduced or zero rates.

3. Do self-employed hairdressers have to pay VAT?

Self-employed hairdressers only need to register for VAT if their taxable turnover exceeds £90,000 in any rolling 12-month period. Below this threshold, they are not required to charge VAT, although voluntary registration is allowed.

4. What do HMRC’s guidelines say about renting a chair in a salon?

According to HMRC, chair rental income is treated as taxable turnover at the standard rate. If a salon rents out chairs to freelance stylists, this rental income counts towards the VAT threshold and must be charged VAT once the threshold is exceeded.

5. Do self-employed hairdressers pay tax to HMRC?

Yes. Self-employed hairdressers must submit a self-assessment tax return each year and pay income tax and national insurance on their profits. VAT is separate and only applies if they cross the registration threshold.

6. Are beauty salons required to be VAT registered?

A beauty salon must register for VAT once its annual taxable turnover exceeds £90,000. If it remains below the threshold, registration is not required. Some salons choose to register voluntarily to reclaim VAT on expenses.

7. What is the VAT threshold in the UK?

From April 2024, the VAT registration threshold is £90,000. Businesses that exceed this limit in any consecutive 12-month period must register with HMRC within 30 days. The deregistration threshold is £88,000.

8. Do hairdressers have to pay VAT on their services?

Yes, once registered. Hairdressers who cross the VAT threshold must add 20% VAT to all their services. Those below the threshold do not charge VAT to customers.

9. Are beauty treatments subject to VAT in the UK?

Yes. All standard beauty treatments, such as facials, manicures, and waxing, are taxed at the 20% VAT rate when the salon or beautician is VAT-registered.

10. Does hairdressing attract GST instead of VAT?

No. The UK does not use GST (Goods and Services Tax). Hairdressing services in the UK are covered under VAT, with the standard rate of 20% applying to all taxable services.

11. Is VAT always 20% for everything in the UK?

No. While many goods and services, including hairdressing and beauty, are taxed at 20%, some items fall under reduced rates (5%) or are zero-rated. For hairdressers, however, services and most products are charged at the standard 20% rate.

How VAT on Urban Planning Services Affects Mixed-Use Developments

Posted on by Sidra

In the UK, VAT on urban planning services can be complex, especially for mixed-use developments that combine residential, commercial, and other property types. Understanding how VAT applies across different project components is essential for urban planning companies, developers, and contractors involved in these types of projects.

VAT Treatment for Residential Projects

For residential projects, planning services are generally exempt from VAT. This means that urban planning companies providing services related to the development of residential properties do not charge VAT to their clients. However, this exemption only applies to the planning services directly related to residential property construction. In some cases, there may be 5% VAT on residential property refurbishment if the works involve qualifying renovations, but this would be a separate issue from planning services.

Commercial Property and VAT

Planning services for commercial projects, on the other hand, are typically subject to VAT at the standard rate of 20%. Urban planning companies must charge VAT on their services related to commercial developments, including retail, office, or industrial properties. This standard VAT rate applies to all professional services related to commercial planning, including architectural plans, site development strategies, and environmental assessments.

Mixed-Use Developments

Mixed-use developments, which combine both residential and commercial elements, present more complexity. For these types of projects, VAT treatment is determined based on the nature of the services being provided. Planning services are typically exempt from VAT if they relate to the residential portions of the project. However, services connected to the commercial areas of the development will be subject to VAT.

In mixed-use projects, it’s important to distinguish which services relate to the residential part of the development and which relate to the commercial part. This allows urban planning companies to apply the correct VAT treatment to different aspects of the project.

VAT on Complex Services

In many cases, urban planning companies may provide a mix of residential and commercial planning services for a single project. The overall VAT treatment may depend on the proportion of work related to each element. For instance, the VAT treatment may favour the exempt rate if residential planning constitutes the majority of the work. Conversely, if the project is predominantly commercial, VAT will likely apply.

What About New Build VAT Exemption?

For planning services related to new builds, residential developments are usually exempt from VAT. However, the New Build VAT Exemption List applies to specific types of construction, which may also include the planning services associated with them. This exemption allows developers to save on VAT costs related to the construction of new homes and residential units.

How to Avoid VAT on Building Work

It’s important to note that urban planning services themselves aren’t usually subject to VAT avoidance strategies, as VAT treatment focuses on construction and building works. However, developers involved in residential or mixed-use projects might benefit from reduced VAT rates on specific building works, such as 5% VAT on building work for certain qualifying refurbishments or residential renovations.

How Apex Accountants Can Help With VAT on Urban Planning Services

At Apex Accountants, we know what it takes to calculate VAT in mixed-use developments and residential projects. Our team of expert tax advisors is well-versed in VAT regulations specific to urban planning and construction. We can help your business navigate the intricate VAT landscape, ensuring that you apply the correct rates to residential, commercial, and mixed-use developments.

Whether you’re unsure about VAT exemptions, need guidance on reclaiming VAT on expenses, or want advice on reducing VAT liabilities, Apex Accountants is here to support you. 

Conclusion

The issue of VAT on planning services for mixed-use developments is not universally applicable. The key to managing VAT correctly lies in understanding the project’s components and how they are classified. Urban planning companies must carefully assess the services provided for residential and commercial sections of a development and apply the appropriate VAT rates. If your business is involved in mixed-use developments, it is essential to seek expert advice to ensure compliance with VAT regulations. Apex Accountants offers expert VAT guidance tailored to urban planning companies. Our experienced team can help you navigate these complexities, ensure that you stay compliant, and optimise your VAT position. Contact us today for expert VAT support in urban planning.

FAQs

  • Are all planning services exempt from VAT in the UK?

No, residential planning services are usually exempt, but commercial planning services are subject to VAT at the standard rate.

  • What is the VAT rate for commercial property planning services?

Commercial planning services are generally subject to VAT at the standard rate of 20%.

  • How is VAT handled in mixed-use developments?

VAT treatment depends on whether the services are related to the residential or commercial part of the project.

  • Can urban planning companies reclaim VAT on expenses?

Yes, urban planning companies can reclaim VAT on expenses related to their taxable services.

  • What should urban planning companies consider when working on mixed-use developments?

Companies must carefully assess the scope of work and apply the correct VAT treatment based on the project components.

  • How does the 5% VAT rate apply to building work?

The 5% VAT rate generally applies to qualifying residential renovations, which might affect the VAT treatment of the overall project.

  • How does the New Build VAT Exemption List impact planning services?

The New Build VAT Exemption List can impact planning services related to new residential developments, allowing for VAT exemptions on construction costs.

Deos Group Wins Major VAT Fraud Appeal Against HMRC

Posted on by Sidra

VAT Fraud Appeal Against HMRC

The First Tier Tribunal (FTT) has delivered a decisive judgement in favour of Southampton-based Deos Group. The company challenged HMRC’s refusal to accept over £1.29 million in input VAT claims and a penalty exceeding £364,000. The VAT fraud appeal case against HMRC focused on whether Deos was aware, or should have been aware, that its supply chain was involved in VAT fraud.

Background To The Deos Group VAT Fraud Appeal

Deos Group, a small business that traditionally sold and leased office equipment, expanded into wholesale consumer electronics during 2021. This move into the ‘grey market’ brought the business under HMRC’s spotlight.

In spring 2022, Deos carried out 18 purchases from one supplier. The input VAT on these transactions totalled £1,299,083.69. HMRC rejected the claims and added a penalty under section 69C of the VAT Act 1994, arguing that the transactions were connected to fraudulent VAT evasion.

HMRC’s VAT Fraud Allegations

According to HMRC, the disputed transactions were tied to fraudulent VAT losses under the Kittel principle. This principle, drawn from European case law, prevents recovery of VAT where the trader knew, or should have known, of fraud in the chain of supply.

The case built by HMRC suggested that unusual pricing patterns and the profile of the supplier should have raised concerns for Deos. HMRC contended that the company either possessed or should have possessed knowledge of fraud associated with the supplies.

The Kittel Principle

The Kittel principle was central to this dispute. It stipulates that VAT cannot be reclaimed on transactions linked to fraud if a trader was, or ought to have been, aware of it. Critics say this principle introduces subjectivity: HMRC can allege that any deviation from its ideal trading model signals knowledge of fraud, even when the trader has no direct connection. For Deos, the question was whether it met the standard of due diligence expected of a reasonable trader.

Deos Group’s Defence

Deos, advised by David Bedenham KC of Keystone Law, argued that it had acted responsibly and carried out appropriate checks. The company stated that its business reasons for entering into the transactions were legitimate and commercially sound.

It was further argued that HMRC’s conclusions were speculative, relying on inferences rather than firm evidence. Documentation and due diligence records were provided to support Deos’s position that it conducted itself in good faith.

Tribunal’s Findings in Deos Group VAT Fraud Case

The Tribunal assessed whether Deos had actual knowledge, or whether a reasonable trader in its position should have known, that the purchases were connected to fraud.

Judge Zachary Citron found that Deos did not cross this threshold. The ruling recognised that:

  • The transactions had valid commercial explanations independent of any fraudulent activity.
  • The due diligence steps taken by Deos were proportionate for a company of its size.
  • HMRC’s VAT fraud allegations did not establish proof of knowledge or wilful blindness.

While acknowledging that fraud existed elsewhere in the supply chain, the Tribunal held that HMRC had not shown Deos to be aware of, or complicit in, that fraud.

Outcome of the VAT Fraud Appeal Against HMRC

The appeal was allowed in full. HMRC’s disallowance of £1.29 million in input VAT was overturned, and the related penalty of £364,220.64 was cancelled.

The judgement underlines an important principle: businesses should not bear penalties for fraud in the supply chain unless there is compelling proof that they knew, or deliberately ignored, such connections. It demonstrates that commercial reasoning and documented due diligence can protect traders against unsubstantiated allegations.

The Deos Group VAT fraud appeal was heard at Taylor House, London, with the decision issued on 21 August 2025. Following the outcome, HMRC announced it was reviewing the judgement and considering its options.

Key Lessons Learned from Deos Group HMRC Case

  • Document every step: Maintain thorough records for supplier checks, contracts, and VAT verification procedures. Proper documentation can help demonstrate that you acted in good faith if HMRC raises questions.
  • Understand your supply chain: Investigate suppliers and sub-suppliers, especially when dealing with wholesale or grey-market goods, to confirm their legitimacy and VAT compliance.
  • Monitor pricing anomalies: Sudden or unexplained price differences can indicate fraud. If a price seems too good to be true, be cautious and consider seeking professional advice.
  • Seek specialist advice early: Don’t wait until HMRC makes an allegation. Consulting a tax specialist or accountant early can help you identify potential VAT risks and mitigate problems before they arise.

Apex Accountants’ Perspective on Deos Group HMRC Case

The appeal by the Deos Group regarding VAT fraud against HMRC is a clear reminder of how important evidence-based decision-making is in tax disputes. From our perspective, the case demonstrates that HMRC cannot rely on assumptions or speculative inferences when challenging a business. A trader’s responsibility is to carry out reasonable due diligence, but the burden of proof remains with HMRC.

This ruling provides reassurance that when proper checks are in place and records are maintained, businesses should not be unfairly penalised for fraud elsewhere in the supply chain. At Apex Accountants, we view this outcome as a significant precedent that strengthens the position of compliant companies who operate in good faith.

How Apex Accountants Can Help

  • Comprehensive VAT risk assessments to identify vulnerabilities in your trading networks and recommend compliance improvements.
  • Supplier due diligence support includes vetting suppliers, checking VAT registration status and ensuring transactions have a legitimate commercial rationale.
  • Representation in HMRC disputes, guiding you through investigations and, if necessary, presenting your case at tribunals.
  • Tailored compliance training for directors and finance teams to recognise potential VAT fraud indicators.

At Apex Accountants, we support businesses facing VAT challenges with clear guidance and practical solutions. Whether you need advice on compliance, help with due diligence, or representation in a dispute, our team is here to assist. Get in touch today to discuss how we can safeguard your business.

Book a Free Consultation